DR. DERRICK HINES, D.P.T. · THE BLOG
Do one thing today
to get a little healthier.
Health & wellness, pain & healing, longevity and life.
|
I have had so many patients come to our office with significant pain problems, only to find out that their insurance is putting a cap on how much treatment they can have, what tests can be run, or what kind of care they can get.
Some days I document a request exactly the way the insurance company asks and still get a no. Other days it goes straight through. Half the time it feels like a coin flip. When I opened the clinic 13 years ago, maybe 3 to 5 percent of our patients wanted to skip insurance and pay cash. Today it is closer to 20 to 25 percent. Almost a quarter. Their deductible is so high that they could come in every day this year and never reach it. We are paying more for insurance than ever. So why does everyone feel like they are getting less? That is the question I put to Dr. Ben Proctor on the Pain & Performance Podcast. Ben is a medical doctor and the author of Inefficient on Purpose. He has also been on the patient side of the exam table, and what happened to him there is the part of this conversation I keep coming back to. You can CLICK HERE to watch the conversation. We Pay Double And Rank Last In 2024, the United States spent about 5.3 trillion dollars on health care. That is roughly $14,775 per person. The average for similar developed countries, like Canada, Germany, France, England and Switzerland, is about $7,800. We spend double. And we do not get more for it. Among ten wealthy countries, the US ranks tenth. Last on access. Last on outcomes. Last on administrative efficiency. Here in Louisiana it is even worse. Families here spend about 15 percent of their income on health insurance, the most of any state. If we were the healthiest state, maybe that would be worth it. We are not. So where is the money going? When They Say No, They Keep Your Premium Most insurers make money by collecting premiums, paying claims and investing what is left. Health insurers have another lever. Prior authorization. Before most tests, treatments or surgeries, your doctor has to ask the insurance company first. A patient has headaches, and the doctor is worried about a brain tumor. The doctor wants an MRI. The insurance company can simply say no. A doctor examined you and decided you need it. The insurer refused to pay. And when that happens, Ben explained, the insurer keeps your premium. Imagine your car insurer refusing to fix your car after a wreck because you did not get prior authorization to drive last week. You would call a lawyer the same day. In health care, it happens every day. Why You Cannot Just Switch If your car insurance did that, you would switch companies tomorrow. Health insurance is different because it is tied to your job. Switching usually means leaving your job, finding another one, and hoping that one has a better plan. When it is that hard to walk away, the insurer has little reason to play fair. Now look at the math. Ben used the example of a thousand dollars a month in premiums, then a deductible of $5,000 to $10,000. Before insurance pays a single dime, you can be around $20,000 in. That is why so many people are cancelling their coverage. And people without enough insurance have worse health outcomes. The Middleman Behind Your Prescription Drug companies get their drugs onto insurance plans through a pharmacy benefit manager, or PBM. The PBM negotiates the list of covered drugs, called a formulary. In the early 2000s, health insurers started buying PBMs. Today, Ben explained, the three biggest PBMs are owned by the three biggest health insurance companies. Their job is no longer to save you money. It is to save the parent company money. So when a plan switches from one drug to a similar one, like Ozempic to Mounjaro, the drug company pays the PBM rebates and fees to win that spot. Ben called it what it is: paying to play. Then there is the clawback. Say the PBM negotiates a drug down from $10 to $8. You still pay $10 at the pharmacy, and the PBM keeps the $2. According to Ben, about 70 percent of the time people pay more for a generic drug with insurance than they would without it. Doctors Cannot Strike Car workers can strike. Doctors cannot. If we stopped showing up, patients would die. So the small changes keep coming, and they add up. Hospitals run on margins of around one percent. The big profits, Ben said, sit with for profit insurers and drug companies. Meanwhile, doctors and hospitals hire whole teams of billing and insurance staff just to fight denials for tests and medicines that were already ordered. Ben estimates that trimming that administrative layer alone could save about 500 billion dollars, and his book puts the total possible savings at over a trillion. Even A Doctor Who Wrote The Book Could Not Escape It Ben was diagnosed in his twenties with CML, a type of leukemia. His medicine kept it undetectable for over ten years. Then in 2025, a prior authorization and a denial delayed his treatment by six weeks. His cancer came back. He is back on treatment now, his numbers are coming down, and he expects to be fine. But think about who this happened to. A physician who literally wrote a book on it. If he cannot get through the system, the everyday person has no shot. It happened to his family too. His eight year old daughter had been doing well on her ADHD medicine for six months when the PBM took it off the formulary on the first of the year. Pay full cash price, or switch her off a medicine that was working. In his practice, Ben had a diabetic patient whose foot ulcer was not healing. He ordered an MRI to check for a bone infection. Insurance denied it. Four months later the patient turned 65, got Medicare, and the MRI showed the bone infection Ben had suspected. Four months that could have cost that patient his foot, or worse. These are not rare stories. Ben shared that one in three doctors have seen a prior authorization denial lead to a poor outcome for a patient. Just under 10 percent say they have lost a patient because of one. Should Health Insurance Be Run For Profit At All? Ben tells a story in the book about firefighting in ancient Rome. A man named Marcus Crassus would show up at a burning building with his brigade and offer to buy it on the spot, for pennies on the dollar. If the owner said no, the brigade stood there and watched it burn. Rome eventually made firefighting a public service. Today, firefighters rush in and put the fire out, and they do not send you a bill. Ben thinks health care can be that important. As he put it, the goal of health care is not to make profit. It is to make people better. I am a business owner. I am fine with profit. But do it helping people. Do not do it hurting people. When an insurer wants a bigger margin, it does not make a better product. It says no more often. What Would Actually Fix It Ben sees two paths. The first is Medicare for All. By the math in his book, it could bring spending under $10,000 per person. He is also honest that he does not see it happening any time soon. The second is regulation, and he thinks it is achievable: Cap the profit a for profit insurer can keep, and require it to pay out a set share of premiums. Keep premium increases close to inflation, not 6 and 10 percent a year. Separate the PBMs from the insurers that own them. Hold insurers liable when a denial leads to harm, the same way a doctor is held liable for a mistake. And let doctors practice medicine. If your doctor says you need a test, you get the test. For now, if a test or medicine you need keeps getting denied, Ben suggests looking at a different plan the following year. And he wants everyday patients to understand why this happens and say so, to their representatives and with their votes. The Takeaway The denials are not a glitch. The system makes money when it says no to your care. Understanding that is the first step to speaking up for yourself. Next time a test or a medicine gets denied, do not just ask whether it is covered. Ask who that decision is really for. Want to go deeper? Ben's book Inefficient on Purpose is available on Amazon, and you can read more at inefficientonpurposebook.com. An audiobook is planned for November. I told my front office they are all reading it. Do one thing today to get a little healthier. Derrick Hines, D.P.T., MS O.M.T. Acadiana Pain & Performance Rehab P.S. Ben and I talk about why health insurance denies your care, who profits when it does, and what would actually fix it. Click HERE to watch the full video on YouTube.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorDerrick Hines, D.P.T. is the owner of Acadiana Pain and Performance Rehab. The information in this blog is personal opinion and not to be used as medical advice. Archives
November 2026
Categories |
|
325 Oil Center Dr. Lafayette, LA 70503
[email protected] |